About

Ohio Senior Insurance

Ohio Senior Insurance is a full-service Health and Wealth Agency, proudly serving Ohio with a dedicated team of Independent Broker/Agents.  We specialize in guiding clients through every phase of retirement with personalized care and expert knowledge. 

Our team includes Social Security Analysts, seasoned Medicare Specialists, and a trusted Financial Fiduciary team - all committed to helping you make informed decisions for a secure and confident future. 

We offer a wide range of services - including Medicare and Rx plans, Dental/Vision, Long Term Care, Home Healthcare, and a host of financial products - all with your needs in mind. 

Whether you are just beginning to plan or are well into retirement, we are here to support your journey every step of the way! 

Our team is available to meet with you, YOUR way: in-office, in-home, online and telephone appointments are available.  All of our services are free to our clients! 

Learn more about Ohio Senior Insurance and how we may be able to help you!

Fill out our online form to request our services or contact either of our offices in Findlay or Defiance.

Denice Hamilton-Short, CLTC, RSSA has almost two decades of experience helping clients with Medicare and Retirement Planning, assisting thousands of people throughout the State of Ohio.

She is the Founder and Owner of Ohio Senior Insurance and has received several industry accolades during her insurance career.  Beginning with achieving Banker's Life and Casualty Rookie of the Year, as well as a Top Producer from several insurance companies, including the Aetna Frontrunner Award, Medical Mutual Top Producer  and Anthem Mega-Star and most recently Anthem's Top Producer in Northwest Ohio.  She is a respected and seasoned veteran in her field.   

Denice holds a National Certification in Long-Term Care Planning and was inducted into the Senior Market Sales President's Club  in 2022. She has a background in hospital management and corporate experience, which has helped her assist clients with healthcare and financial planning decisions while mentoring new agents.

Over the years, Denice has seen many changes in the Medicare and Financial Planning industry.  She brings that valuable knowledge and insight to those she serves.  She is constantly investing in herself and the Ohio Senior Insurance agents to develop new skills as the industry changes.   

In 2025, Denice also obtained her Registered Social Security Analyst (RSSA) designation. 

She is licensed in Ohio, Indiana, Michigan, Tennessee, Florida, Arizona, and Alabama and plans to expand services and teams across the country.

Denice has two sons, Joshua (daughter-in-law, Aspen) and Matthew.  She is also the proud grandmother to two amazing grandchildren, Elizabeth and Henry. 

Talk To Denice

Stephanie Wagner joined Ohio Senior Insurance with over 23 years of diverse healthcare experience and a passion for guiding clients through the Medicare process. A native of the Defiance, Ohio area, Stephanie built a strong foundation working in various healthcare settings, including nursing homes, hospitals, physician offices, pharmacies, and home healthcare. Her firsthand experience in the healthcare industry gives her a unique perspective and deep understanding of the needs of Medicare-eligible individuals. 

Stephanie specializes in helping clients navigate Medicare with clarity and confidence. Whether it’s Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage, Part D prescription plans, or supplemental coverage (Medigap), she provides personalized guidance to ensure her clients receive the coverage that best fits their healthcare needs and financial goals. 

Since joining Ohio Senior Insurance, she has become a trusted resource for clients new to Medicare as well as those reviewing their current plans. Her client-focused approach and dedication to simplifying the Medicare process have made her a valued advisor and advocate for the individuals and families she serves. 

Miss Wagner is an Independent Licensed Agent with Ohio Senior Insurance and is licensed in the state of Ohio. 

Her mission is to help clients feel informed, confident, and supported every step of the way as they make important decisions about their health coverage. 

Talk To Stephanie

Amanda Nigh is a Licensed Independent Insurance Agent with Ohio Senior Insurance, proudly serving clients in Ohio and Florida. With over three years of experience in the insurance industry, Amanda is passionate about simplifying complex healthcare and insurance choices for her clients, helping them feel secure and confident in their decisions. 

Amanda brings a strong background in healthcare and nursing home care to her role, along with personal experience assisting family and friends through their own healthcare journeys. These experiences inspired her to pursue a career as a licensed agent, where she now specializes in Social Security Retirement sign-ups, Medicare enrollment, and both Life and Medicare Insurance coverage. 

She has called Ohio home for over 12 years, where she lives with her husband, Bill, and their three children. She is known for her ability to establish lasting relationships with clients, always ensuring they receive insurance solutions tailored to their specific needs and goals. 

In her free time, Mrs. Nigh enjoys gardening, cooking, and volunteering at the Veterans of Foreign Wars local chapter. She is deeply committed to giving back to her community and is proud to be a part of the dedicated team at Ohio Senior Insurance. 

Talk To Amanda

Matthew joined the Ohio Senior Insurance Team in 2022 after attending Bowling Green State University majoring in Business Administration. 

Matthew is a dedicated and knowledgeable insurance professional with 3 years of first-hand experience in the life and health insurance industry.  Certified in the Federal Marketplace/ACA insurance program, he is committed to helping individuals and families navigate their health coverage options with confidence and clarity. 

In addition to his ACA expertise, Matthew provides personalized support to Medicare beneficiaries ensuring they understand and select plans that best fit their needs.  He also offers guidance on a variety of life insurance solutions helping clients plan for the future and protect what matters most. 

Matthew continues to develop new skills in the insurance industry and is currently working towards his Investment Advisor designation to further assist his clients. 

Known for his approachable demeanor and attention to detail, Matthew takes pride in providing reliable client-focused service to his clients.

Matthew is an avid sports fan and enjoys golfing at any opportunity. 

Talk To Matthew

Aspen Short is excited to continue her career with Ohio Senior Insurance, bringing her insurance experience and passion for helping others to the team. Aspen has been a licensed Health and Life Insurance Agent since 2022. She previously worked with Ohio Senior Insurance before joining Wood Haven Health Care, where she gained valuable experience working closely with individuals and families and developed an even greater appreciation for helping people navigate important decisions. An active member of her community, Aspen is involved with the Wood County Chamber of Commerce and other local organizations. She enjoys volunteering, building relationships, and finding meaningful ways to give back to the community. Outside of work, Aspen enjoys spending time with her husband, Joshua, and their two children, Elizabeth and Henry. Her family enjoys camping, spending time outdoors, and making memories together. Aspen looks forward to building lasting relationships with her clients and helping individuals and families better understand their insurance options so they can make informed decisions with confidence.

Wendy joined the Ohio Senior Insurance team in 2024, focusing on helping clients resolve coverage issues and answering healthcare questions for both new and existing clients. In June 2026, Wendy became a licensed insurance agent, expanding her ability to assist our community with health and life insurance needs.

Before joining Ohio Senior Insurance, Wendy worked for 30 years at Cooper Tire in Findlay, where she focused on customer service.



A native of the Findlay area, Wendy and her husband, Chuck, enjoy spending time with their family—especially their grandchildren.

Talk To Wendy